But wait, were already getting down to the brass tacks before Ive even had a proper shot at setting anything up, which is pretty much what Beth did when she first clocked Summers naively unaware face. The Yellowstone universe is constantly evolving. And that, fellow viewers, is the theme of this weeks rundown, as some extremely alarming moments played out in Horses in Heaven, while others tapped into different emotional zones, leaving behind various levels of worry for the Dutton family. However, John Dutton III from Yellowstone never talks about a lost or deceased brother. So he gets a free pass in this case, but just this one. Article ID: 21661. But will having a second knockdown, drag-out fight at least be enough to curb those violent urges for at least a few weeks of Johns governorship? This would point to Ned and Chance Dutton being brothers of 1883s John Dutton Sr (grandfather of Kevin Costners John). So is his exact place in the family bloodline. Learn More, The Dutton family dynamic is certainly an interesting one. While the gravestones are partially blocked by grass, fans were able to identify a date on Neds gravestone as March 16, 1863. He worked the Yellowstone land alongside . Last appearance The headstones did not look that old. We've marked that as speculation since it's not been confirmed. "Flashback to show that you have a son," another chimed in. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. And it wont, because it cant, because hes Jamie. Truly, I may not have been so eager to question her stone in particular had it not been for that timely close-up that soon followed Monica saying to Summer: If your goal is knowing John Dutton, then this is exactly where you should be. No reason to start with anything else here, since Beths drunken and petty attack, along with its aftermath, capped off the episode. 1 of Season 5 of Yellowstone, Jamie Dutton introduces Governor John Dutton as a fifth-generation rancher. All the more bawl-worthy was learning what theyd named the boy, as it presumably makes him the fourth-generation John, cementing that part of the family legacy not-so-coincidentally around the point when Paramount Network aired the first teaser for 1923, the upcoming prequel with Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren. The bonds of their marriage have been stretched beyond their limits, only to reform again around the fissure. In Yellowstone, John Dutton proclaims that generations of Duttons have found their final resting place at their ranch. His love for his wife and daughters is almost equaled by his love of gasp-for-breath laughter and gasp-for-breath horror. Did 'Grey's Anatomy' Set Up Ellen Pompeo's Return? ), Below are the five biggest concerns Im bouncing between following Episode 504 (with a geotracker collar around my leg to fool Fish & Wildlife officers), starting with everyones favorite rabble-rouser. Wes Bentley- "Jamie Dutton" The Dutton family tree is pretty complicated, but it doesn't have to be. It doesnt seem like any major characters are destined for the ol train station in the sky, as the reactions in the preview didnt seem quite that grave. Therefore, his death would predate Elsas death and the Dutton familys arrival in Paradise Valley. And that, unfortunately, is where the information stops. I doubt it, but I sorta hope it happens, and that we get a cage fight by the end of Season 5. The Dutton Ranch men ambushed him and managed to pull him off his horse with a lasso, then hung him from a tree after cutting the Dutton brand off of him. Could that seemingly random encounter have been purposefully set up for scandal-causing reasons? We assume that one was one of the Duttons buried on the ranch.. Even though John expressly mentioned to his new driver not to divulge details of his candid conversations with the kiddos, his early days as Montanas new governor havent exactly kept his truest motives hidden, even if hes fooling some into thinking he cares about the state or its citizens as much as he cares about Paradise Valley. But in an episode where the protagonists made rash actions that may not have been so smart, I cant knock the guy for thinking before leaping. "Since 1886, every Dutton who died is buried 300 yards from my back porch. Both headstones and the style and size of the font of the engravings were the same, as well was the age and wear of the stone. Also, see our Dutton family tree infographic to help you understand the Dutton family lineage we discuss. John Dutton, played by Kevin Costner, is the patriarch of a ranching family and owner of the largest ranch in the U.S. Dutton's Yellowstone Ranch borders the national park of the same name, a. To the episodes credit, I suppose, Sheridan & Co. telegraphed these scenes to set off massive alarm bells within viewers and buffer the shock of the tragedy to come. A new theory suggests it could be Thomas Rainwater's assistant, Mo. Take these two Duttons, for example. Along with heightening the threat of danger that comes with traversing the vast land by their lonesome, Rip may have also just been trying to get the officers defensive and less observant with his aggressive attitude. chance dutton headstone yellowstone chance dutton headstone yellowstone. And in that respect, I cant tell if I truly buy into Beths 15 feet tall and bulletproof attitude dulling her comprehension that breaking the law in public actively goes against the instincts of any governors chief of staff. Super frustrating. Which likely means Jamie will continue to walk along the edge with his latest lapse in professional judgment, she who calls herself Sarah Atwood. Yellowstone gave viewers an impromptu throwdown that mirrored Season 4s last man standing brawl between Lloyd and Walker. When it comes to not-so-innocent Duttons, Im more than a little worried that. Once authorities with a Dutton-hating stick up their rear start looking into things happening at the Y, is there ever a point when they'd stop looking? One last theory comes from the fact that John Dutton II had at least one more son, whose identity is unknown. This page provides an overview of 3D Surdo maps in the Maphill world atlas. Im not saying she should have expected to get clocked by a bottle, but I just literally cant conceive what led her to think the outcome would be positive enough to justify making the trip across the dancefloor. Taylor Sheridan's creation has expanded to include the Dutton family origin story with 1883 and 1923, and with new installments (1883: The Bass Reeves Story and 6666) on the horizon, we don't expect the world to be simplified any time soon. New episodes of Yellowstone are set to air each Sunday night on Paramount Network. Ranch owner John Dutton ends up in a traffic accident as he . The rest of the video (and what follows here) is the more detailed explanation. Yellowstone fans know that Duttons have been buried in the same spot in Montana for over a century. ?,," one fan asked. 7Ruby18 is leading this charge, and has the following to report: I just rechecked Lees funeral scene to look at the headstones frame-by-frame. Not to take away from the importance of his beliefs and the act in general, but I have to believe that the negative effect Kayce stepping down will have on Johns early run as Governor will be more substantial than the positive effect itll have on his home life. 3D maps show Surdo, Cosenza, Calabria, Italy and the surrounding region at elevation angle of 60. But will Sarah have what it takes to convincingly turn Jamie against the fam, given all the evidential fuel that Beth has on him? Chance and Ned Dutton have been a mystery to the viewers. Its probably only a matter of time before he becomes fully infatuated, which would easily allow Sarah to take over as a puppeteer for his legal wrangling talents. Sharp fans have even taken to going back to check Lee Duttons funeral. Resolved: Release in which this issue/RFE has been resolved. Good Housekeeping participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. 20 Best Modern Western TV Shows for Cowboy Lovers, You Can Spend the Night at the Iconic Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, James sister Claire before she shot herself she said she had lost all 7 of her children His brother Jacob and his wife Cars had no children Maybe just one week? RIP software can design all sorts of print materials in a wide range of sizes. At 75-years-old, Shea tells James that in the six months he's known Elsa, he can tell she has lived, smiled and loved more in her short time than he has. After Lees death, he is buried on the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch among other deceased members of the family. Anyone entering John Duttons inner circle needs around 15 rounds of vetting, but she came out of nowhere as far as viewers are concerned, and is working with John out of duty, as opposed to out of loyalty. Read More:Does Jamie Die in Yellowstone? Beth might think shes in one of Taylor Sheridans prequels, where busting up other peoples faces is as much a way of life as living by the law, but thats obviously not the case here. But for comparisons sake, her marker looks less aged than those next to her, with the carvings appearing darker. Which, by all means, is probably what everyone watching at home expected him to do, all while presumably razzing Jamie and Lynelle for trying to convince John to make less tumultuous directions. Since the idea of Tate wanting them to have another baby was mentioned just as many times as Kayce seeing the end of their relationship during his vision quest, it makes me more than wary about any attempts they make to get pregnant anew. Clawing his eyes out with her bare hands may indeed be the only authentic way for her to sate the bloodthirst within. John Dutton I. He's a young man who helped his father and great-uncle (Jacob Dutton) on their relatively new land. We know of 9 airports in the vicinity of Surdo, of which 3 are . The other explanation is that Clare married a third Dutton boy, but that wouldn't explain why herdaughter the late Mary Abel has a different last name. John Dutton III, Chance Dutton John mentions Chance during the burial of Lee in the Yellowstone pilot. But any attempts to feel joy about such miracles were clearly destined for doom as soon as Monica confidently declared she would drive herself to the hospital. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. John lll (Kevin Costner) had a brother Peter who died only after a few days of being born. Yellowstone Season 3 concludes on. Hopefully it just means Rip starts telling Dad jokes more often. 2023 horseyhooves.com, part of the Hopnetic network. John Dutton III, Chance Dutton John mentions Chance during the burial of Lee in the Yellowstone pilot. (Paramount Network) Beware of 'spoilers' from here on down! But in the way that there will always be LEGO-esque building blocks standing alongside the monolith, it stands to reason there are other people in the world who share similar outlooks and playbooks with Kelly Reillys stinger-covered queen bee. 4.10 Grass on the Streets and Weeds on the Rooftops, 5.06 Cigarettes, Whiskey, a Meadow and You. This 'Yellowstone' Flashback Could Be a Clue That Elsa Dutton is Pregnant on '1883' Newsweek proposed this theory earlier today. But recently, one eagle-eyed fan on Reddit realized that Lee was actually absent from a number of flashback scenes when his character was still very much alive. Chance Dutton on Yellowstone /a > Prediction: Phyllis was Evelyns.. You, ever. If the second John Sr. (Coleman) were Spencer's boy, that would wipe out a full generation and only make Costner's John a fourth-generation rancher. Considering each move hes making is just widening the target on his back, and lengthening the list of people who are aiming at it, one would imagine hell have to quickly reach a point where he understands that breaking all the rules will make it harder to enforce the ones that are keeping his land safe. In the series premiere episode of Yellowstone, viewers see the death of John Duttons eldest son, Lee Dutton. Moreover, the creator has made the drama full of mystery. The simplest explanation I can think of is that at some point after her husband died in 1893, Margaret put the call out to her brother-in-law Jacob to come and live/work on the ranch, and then perhaps struck out on her own, unable to continue living in the same place where her daughter and husband were both killed by others. As seen in the preview for Episode 6 and as hinted at by the general ominous vibe tied to virtually everyone leaving the ranch for two full days something big and not-so-great is going to go down while John & Co. are out and about. Tate Dutton is the seventh generation, and unless Kayce and Monica have more kids, he's it. For as much as Yellowstones flashbacks appear to be setting up some emotional catalysts for certain characters, you wouldnt know it by looking at Rips face throughout Season 5 so far. Theres still time for that, though. It gets confusing here, because therearetwo unique characters called John Dutton Sr. Never a dull moment for the Dutton family, which is also to say never a dull dinner. At face value, it means Summer learning about the family is the best way to understand Kevin Costners patriarch. We know it can't be Ned Dutton, so it could be Chance Dutton. The opening episode of 1923 reveals that Jacob rushed to save the family upon James' death. I figured, I just thought there would be some significance to showing their names, but obviously nothing has ever come from it. by Sophie Cook March 3, 2023, 4:03 pm. Wisely, her introduction is more low-key, where she shows off her me-first confidence and wiles without being outwardly vile or villainous. So lets lace up our gloves and step into the ring that is the Duttons front yard. She also has a soft spot for feel-good TV, so you can catch her writing about popular shows like Virgin River, Sweet Magnolias, Hallmark Channels When Calls the Heart and more. Ned's headstone says 3/16/1863 so if he is buried there, he died after 1886 according to John's speech at the Stockman's Dinner. Chance Dutton Yellowstone is full of familial mysteries. No one just walks up off the street and takes Beth on. Lets take a closer look at some of the biggest and wildest choices made by Yellowstones elite throughout Episode 503, and how they could affect things quite negatively moving forward. The names of Ned and Chance Dutton are never spoken on the screen. 6 Big Yellowstone Questions After Episode 505 And Beth's Latest Bloody Fight, Yellowstone: My Biggest Worries After Episode 504, Including That Beth And Jamie Reveal, Yellowstones Worst Character Decisions From Episode 503, Including Beths Violent Night Out, Yellowstone's Most Important Takeaways From Season 5's Double-Ep Premiere, Including That Tragic Death, Ahead Of Renfield, Nicolas Cage Makes Case For His Dracula To Get A Solo Movie, Yellowstones Piper Perabo And Lainey Wilson Shared Thoughts On Those Wild Kevin Costner Rumors, James Gunn Explains Why He's Now Making A Superman Movie After Previously Turning Down The Opportunity, Star Trek: Discovery Is Ending With Season 5 On Paramount+, But There Is Good News, Disneyland Had A Classic Reaction As Fans Shared Posts Of It Snowing In The California Parks This Week. Along with all of James and Margaret's kids, they make up the "white" generation. When 1883 first introduced Elsa Dutton to be something of a polar opposite to Beth, a lot of fans likely envisioned an impossible reality where the two characters could meet up and shoot the. A lifetime spent in the vicinity of a television screen led to his current dream job, as well as his knowledge of too many TV themes and ad jingles. Itd be one thing if these markers featured lowercase letters that would account for the A being curved, but the AGED carving below proves thats not the case. I think theyre related to John Dutton 2 (Kevin Cs fathrr character). .css-lwn4i5{display:block;font-family:Neutra,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.01rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;text-align:center;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-lwn4i5:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-lwn4i5{font-size:1.375rem;line-height:1.1;}}Christina Hendricks Flaunts Strong Legs In IG Pics, Adam Sandler's Wife Jackie Shuts Down Red Carpet, Sam Heughan Posted a Heartbreaking IG on Season 7, See Riley Keough's Tribute to Lisa Marie Presley, Savannah Guthrie Wore a See-Through Lace Dress. "Are you coming back to Yellowstone as a flashback!?? That's because Beth Dutton can't have children, Lee Dutton is dead and Jamie is the family black sheep. The drama came up with its fourth season on 7 November 2021. Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. The Version table provides details related to the release that this issue/RFE will be addressed. When Yellowstone first started, Kayce Dutton and his nuclear family were living on a reservation near the Dutton ranch. in this quasi-relationship, with Dawn Olivieris character wholeheartedly appealing to his sexual desires in place of his law-degree logic. During season four, Kayce decides to move his family . For example, they pointed out several instances when they showed family photos in earlier seasons and Lee was nowhere to be found. Fans who have re-watched the show (or had a rather thorough first watch) may remember hearing of Chance and Ned Dutton. ---- So I guess she put all of that energy into the motivation to brawl, even though she should have known that using any kind of weapon in the process would lead to bigger repercussions. Spirited Elsa ( Isabel May) was the eldest child of James and Margaret Dutton and served as the narrator of 1883. To circle back to what was just mentioned: am I worried about Rip finding out the role Jamie played in Beths abortion? Lee is mysteriously absent in all the flashbacks and family photos. (As well as questions about where Josh Lucas fan-rousing younger John Dutton was this week. 'Yellowstone' shows the graves of Ned and Chance Dutton In Yellowstone Season 5, Summer Higgins explores the Dutton family cemetery. Those who watched 1883 remember a Crow elder telling McGraw's James Dutton that he could have the land he was sent to to bury his daughter, but in seven generations, the tribe would take it back. But it seems like all the tombstones that have popped up on the show belong only to relations, leaving viewers to wonder what happens to all of the various ranch employees that have helped do the Duttons dirty work for the past 100+ years? During 1883,Claire meets her fate. But a breaking point exists, and John is on his way to plowing right through it by filling his ranks with his inner circle. We don't know too much about Chance, only that he is John's brother and may have. Like the dialogue noted above, this line could be taken two different ways. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. She has to rise up from somewhere, after all, if shes going to one day ram heads with the Duttons fiercest warrior. Surdo in Provincia di Cosenza (Calabria) with it's 1,659 citizens is a city in Italy about 262 mi (or 422 km) south-east of Rome, the country's capital city. John Dutton (Kevin Costner) Image via Paramount Network. Hence, Elsas grave marks the foundation of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. Early episodes of Yellowstone show tombstones for Ned and Chance Dutton, who both lived in the mid to late 19th century. Thanks to Rubys sleuthing, however, we do know that at least Ned Dutton wouldve been a contemporary of 1883s John Dutton Sr., played by tiny Audie Rick for that series (in the Yellowstone Season 4 flashback, hes played by another, older actor). This post may contain affiliate links. In the series, the Dutton family holds their land dear to them and will never give it up at any cost. Some fans have a far-fetched theory that Lee was the person behind the camera, but other have chalked it up to "sloppy writing.". Of course, his inflated sense of victory and/or pride was falsely earned, as Sarah and Ellis were of course playing him right from the start. So lets take a closer look at what may or may not have been shown. Yellowstone's first episode weaves. Nah, that shits been coming for a long time, and I am so ready to start hollering at my TV when it happens, hopefully as Season 5 heads into its winter hiatus, giving way to Paramount+'s upcoming prequel 1923. Jennifer Borresen USA TODAY Published 11:07 am UTC Dec. 15, 2022 Updated 10: . Additionally, I would have said the sheriffs decision to send Beth to jail was a dumb move, given whatever Dutton-originated firestorm is coming his way, but it was literally the only move he could have made with all those people around, particularly the woman threatening to press charges on Beth. But if all that is true, then why doesnt that tombstone look like it ever had the name JAMES carved into it? Ned's headstone says 3/16/1863 so if he is buried there, he died after 1886 according to John's speech at the Stockman's Dinner. Where her main motivation should be to keep out of any trouble that could draw negative attention to Johns atypical maneuvers as Montanas governor, her actual mission statement appears to be Gotcha, bitch. She couldnt just let sleeping (with her father) dogs lie by giving Summer her space, not that Piper Perabos homebound activist made her face any less punchable by railing on Gators dinner spread. (Funnily enough, a particular females sexual activities were at the heart of both fights.) The moment of strife didnt have lengthy consequences within their relationship, thankfully, but I can easily see a scenario where Rip calmly talked to her without anyone else around and convinced her to stick around the ranch that night. Click here to refresh the page. Im rewatching everything from the beginning with my husband. Just to get it straight right from the start: there is only ONE Beth Dutton, and there will only ever be one Beth Dutton. As Redditor DrBCraft asks fellow fans: Forgive me if this is obvious or has been addressed before somewhere on this subreddit But do we know who Chance and Ned Dutton are? Even with the release of 1883, there is still a lot we dont know about this powerful family. James Dutton (Tim McGraw), the lead of 1883 is John. Sure itd be a powerful enough narrative conceit for Beth to continue looking back with regret to a time in which she allowed immature feelings to blot out a potential relationship with Rip. The series, a reimagination of the classic western genre in a contemporary setting, follows the fictional Dutton family who fights tooth and nail against enemies on every side as they hold onto their titular Yellowstone ranch in Montana, which is their home and family legacy. Im not worried that Beth would do anything violent, considering shed be so willing to have a child herself if it was possible, but the fact that its not possible is obviously her fuel here. Im more than a bit worried that. Fans met days of Dutton past first with Yellowstone prequel 1883, and now we're being introduced to the next lineage in the latest installment of the story: 1923.The tale of Cara and Jacob . Only Taylor Sheridan knows for sure. Before knowing Jamie was adopted, I had a suspicion for some time that Lee was not John 3s son, but instead a son Chance or Neds son. There are two episodes left to go before Yellowstones winter hiatus, which will pave the way for 1923s debut on Paramount+, which will eventually lead back around to the second half of the flagships fifth season. Chance Dutton's gravestone as shown in John Dutton's memory We obviously know that the Duttons keep their nearest and dearest family members close to home after theyve passed, but what about the many hands who have joined the bleedin bunkhouse invisible? Tim McGraw plays James Dutton in the . Dave Annable. Both couples have certainly shown the kind of passion that leads to baby-making. Im not actually worried that this top-tier character would suffer by bringing the act of considering into her bag of tricks, and not only because Kelly Reilly is flawless in any capacity. Just doing the math of the stones makes this possible and either when the stones are shown could just be a flashback (you know dad burying son(s)) or just a family honor thing of having markers for your family dead. Like, I can get someone on the outer perimeter like Gator having a personal life away from the ranch, even if hes spending sooo much time cooking for the Duttons and various guests. Whats more, Taylor Sheridans writing also skews intentionally vague in a way that raises questions about whether or not the man weve known to be James Dutton is actually the first John. But even beyond the threat of jailtime and more for Ryan and Colby for doing the wolf-killing, Yellowstone appears to be setting up more of a layered story here. From fleeing a life of poverty to owning the largest cattle ranch in Montana, the family has come a long way. As the show progresses, we can only hope to learn about more members of the Dutton family. Just super random. [1] Chance's birth date and the date of his death are unknown. Because he now has more understanding than ever before of how to read between her lines and know what she truly wants, even if shes outwardly stating the opposite. We earn from qualifying purchases. Our best guest is she's a second child to Jack and Elizabeth, although Spencer and Alex could have also given birth to a daughter. That math only works if this John Sr. (Coleman) is great-grandson to James (McGraw). John continued to make it clear where he stands on Jamies place within the family by referring to him as the child he regrets, and not counting him amongst his sons. Interestingly, Ned Duttons grave is marked with the year 1863. For what i's worth, I've spent a few hours trying to find out who Ned and Chance Dutton were and found nothing. But unless Margaret (Faith Hill) and James Dutton (Tim McGraw) have two more boys well into their 50s, this isnt the case (which wouldve been highly unlikely in the 19th century at their age). Why woud you go through the trouble and expense of erecting headstones for people whose bodies aren't even buried under them, that are actually thousands of miles away? But considering their conversation largely revolves around John Dutton as an entity, could just as easily have been implying he was the first in the family to don that name. Its been a wild week for everyone, which is part of why Im worried that. By watching 1883, we know neither made the trip to Montana with James and Margaret. Local time in Surdo is now 07:24 PM (Wednesday). Fixed: Release in which this issue/RFE has been fixed.The release containing this fix may be available for download as an Early Access Release or a General Availability Release. This is circa 1895. By all means, all the power to her for taking the initiative to start a conversation with Rip, as hes the epitome of a cowboy bar catch. You will receive a verification email shortly. That's no good. Up to this point, Jamies son with Christina Lil Jamie Dueces is what Id like to call him doesnt seem to have had a rough life yet, despite unwittingly losing his grandfather in a similar way to his grandmother. From my great-great-grandfather, to my wife, and my oldest son, said John. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. It is unknown who Chance and Ned Dutton are. Rip Wheeler 47 Episodes 2022. Took three seasons for us to learn that Jamie wasnt Johns son," another fan commented. Aside from promoting the show's Memorial Day marathon, the last time the actor posted about Yellowstone was on the day of the season 2 premiere, joking he's "not sure how the show made it to a season 2 with its biggest name being offed in the first episode.". How would we know? Chance and Ned are among them; two Duttons we dont know enough about to firmly place on a family tree. Yellowstone, 1883 and 1923 fans will appreciate this easy explanation of how James, Jacob and John Dutton are related. The stunning Montana ranch that serves as the setting for the hit TV show, Yellowstone Stars Speak Out on Rumors Show Is Ending Over Kevin Costner Drama, Yellowstone Newcomer Orli Gottesman Has Never Even Met Kevin Costner, 1923 Stars Share the Hardest Part of Filming the Yellowstone Prequel, 1923: Alexandras Big Royal Secret, Revealed + Explained [Dutton Rules], Sam Elliott + Wife Katharine Ross Are All Smiles on the 2023 SAG Awards Carpet [Pictures], Sam Elliott Collects a Screen Actors Guild Award for 1883: What a Gift [Watch], Actor Wes Bentley Shrugs Off Yellowstone Rumors: Probably a Bit of Drama Over Nothing, 1923 Season Finale Brings a New Romance, a Shocking Death + a Cliffhanger We Did Not See Coming [Spoilers Alert].

Mackay Rugby League Grand Final, Jenna And Ashleigh Great White Sharks, Dallas Cowboys Director Of College Scouting, Articles C